logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-36865659
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-36865659
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
by R AssociatesNovember 11, 2026 Recent News0 comments

HERC Rejects Review Petition, Holds Section 142 Proceedings Cannot Reopen Concluded Issues and Enforcement Proceedings Must Remain Within the Four Corners of the CGRF Order

Case No. HERC/RA 07 of 2026 | Judgment dated 15 October 2026

 The Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission (‘HERC’), vide order dated 15.10.2026in Shri Ram Filament v. SDO, DHBVN & Anr., Case No. HERC/RA 07 of 2026, rejected the review petition challenging its order dated 16.01.2026 in Petition No. 71 of 2024.

HERC held that review jurisdiction cannot be used to re-agitate issues already considered and decided, and that proceedings under Section 142 of the Electricity Act, 2003 cannot be used to enlarge the relief granted by the Consumer Grievance Redressal Forum (“CGRF”). The Commission further held that interest could not be claimed on an ACD amount which had not actually been deposited with the distribution licensee.

Dispute

Shri Ram Filament, an industrial consumer of Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (‘DHBVN’), had approached the CGRF alleging, inter alia, issues concerning adjustment of its Advance Consumption Deposit (‘ACD’) and payment of interest.

By order dated 22.03.2024, the CGRF directed DHBVN to adjust ₹4,71,899/- towards ACD along with interest at 18% from January 2019 till realization, with the order further clarifying that the 18% rate applied for the period during which payment of interest was delayed.

In view of the delay in adjustment of ACD and interest amount by DHBVN, Shri Ram Filament instituted Petition No. 71 of 2024 under Section 142 of the Electricity Act, 2003(‘Act’), alleging non-compliance with the directions of the CGRF. Pursuant to the directions issued by HERC in the said proceedings, DHBVN subsequently refunded ₹7,10,151/-, comprising the ACD principal, statutory interest and penal interest for the delay. By order dated 16.01.2026, HERC recorded that the directions contained in the CGRF order had been complied with and that nothing further remained for adjudication.

The Review Applicant thereafter sought review, principally contending that further interest was payable on an alleged enhanced ACD of ₹40,97,195/-, subsequently stated to be ₹45,47,805/-, and that the computation of interest on the original ACD had also been incorrectly made.

Review Cannot Operate as an Appeal

HERC reiterated that the jurisdiction under Section 94(1)(f) of the Act is limited to recognised grounds of review, including an error apparent on the face of the record, discovery of new and important evidence despite due diligence, or other sufficient reason.

The Review Applicant had not identified any such error or new evidence. Its challenge essentially sought reconsideration of the calculations and findings already examined by the Commission.

Section 142 Proceedings Cannot Enlarge the CGRF Order

HERC held that the CGRF order dated 22.03.2024 specifically directed adjustment of ₹4,71,899/- with interest. It did not direct payment of interest on the separate enhanced ACD amount. HERC therefore rejected the attempt to expand the scope of the CGRF order through compliance proceedings.

HERC relied upon the principle that proceedings under Section 142 are confined to examining compliance with the order whose enforcement is sought. They cannot be converted into proceedings for modification, enlargement or fresh adjudication of the substantive relief granted in that order.

No Interest on ACD Not Actually Deposited

HERC also rejected the claim for interest on the alleged ACD of ₹40,97,195/-. HERCfound that the amount had not been deposited with DHBVN during the relevant period and therefore could not be treated as an ACD/security deposit carrying interest for that period.

Compliance with the CGRF Order Had Already Been Recorded

HERC relied upon its order dated 16.01.2026, in which it had already recorded that DHBVN had complied with the CGRF directions by adjusting the ACD along with applicable interest.

The position was also subsequently recorded in proceedings before the Hon’ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in CWP No. 3855 of 2026, where the Review Applicant acknowledged compliance with the CGRF order. HERC therefore found no basis to reopen the issue through review proceedings.

Regulatory Significance

The order reinforces two important procedural limits under the Act. First, review jurisdiction is not an avenue for a second adjudication. A party cannot seek reconsideration of an issue merely because it disputes HERC’s appreciation of calculations or interpretation of material already considered.

Second, enforcement under Section 142 is confined to the order sought to be enforced. The enforcement forum cannot enlarge the substantive relief granted by the original adjudicating authority or read additional monetary entitlements into an order which does not contain them.

Judgement Link:

Read More
Share
by R AssociatesOctober 9, 2026 Recent News0 comments

An Unchallenged Regulatory Order Bars a Fresh Petition on the Same Tariff — Appeal No. 325 of 2026

Haryana Power Purchase Centre v. M/s Siwana Solar Power Projects Ltd. & Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission decided on 18 September 2026 

Background

HPPC and Siwana executed a PPA in 2014 for a 5 MW solar plant. Clause 4.1 fixed the applicable tariff as the lowest of three options: the HERC (State Commission) generic tariff, the lowest tariff accepted in HPPC’s first long-term competitive bidding tender, or the lowest tariff in HAREDA’s first reverse-bidding tender. A tariff of Rs. 6.44/kWh was discovered. HERC, by order dated 20.01.2026, held Siwana bound by the PPA and directed year-to-year tariff corresponding to a levelized Rs. 6.44/kWh. That order was upheld by Appellate Tribunal for Electricity on 27.05.2019 in Appeal No. 150 of 2016.

Separately, PPAs with four other developers under the same tender were initially rejected by HERC and Appellate Tribunal by judgment dated 09.03.2018 in Appeal Nos. 278 and 307 of 2016 directed their approval at Rs. 5.68/kWh. The Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed the developers’ appeals on 10.10.2023. HPPC thereafter paid Siwana at Rs. 5.68/kWh  and HERC by order dated 10.05.2019 permitted that rate as an interim arrangement.

Siwana’s Petition No. 26 of 2024, seeking implementation of Rs. 6.44/kWh was dismissed in limine by HERC on 12.11.2024 on the principles of res judicata. No appeal was filed against that order. Siwana then filed Petition No. 78 of 2025 and HERC by the impugned order dated 14.05.2026 granted Rs. 6.44/kWh from 1 April 2019, with differential tariff, interest at 9.15% per annum and late payment surcharge.

Findings

On res judicata. HERC’s order dated 12.11.2024 had held that the sum and substance of all of Siwana’s petitions was the grant of Rs. 6.44/kWh, that the issue had attained finality and that res judicata applied. That order went unchallenged. Comparing the prayers in Petition No. 26 of 2024 and Petition No. 78 of 2025, the Appellate Tribunal found them identical, the parties the same and the subject-matter the same. Applying Section 11 CPC and Syed Mohd. Salie Labbai v. Mohd. Hanifa, (1976) 4 SCC 780, Satyadhyan Ghosal v. Deorajin Debi, 1960 SCC OnLine SC 15, Sulochana Amma v. Narayanan Nair, (1994) 2 SCC 14, Swamy Atmananda v. Sri Ramakrishna Tapovanam, (2005) 10 SCC 51, Bhanu Kumar Jain v. Archana Kumar, (2005) 1 SCC 787 and M. Nagabhushana v. State of Karnataka, (2011) 3 SCC 408, the Appellate Tribunal held that the doctrine operates even where the earlier decision may be erroneous, the remedy lying in appeal or review and not in fresh litigation.

The “past dues versus prospective tariff” distinction drawn by HERC in the impugned order was held to be legally unsustainable. The impugned order was set aside.

Read More
Share
by R AssociatesJuly 22, 2026 Recent News0 comments

APTEL Upholds that Delay in Securing Long-Term Access (LTA) is not a valid Force Majeure and Therefore, Scheduled Delivery Date under PPA Cannot be Unilaterally Extended

In a judgment dated 03.07.2026 in Appeal No.183 of 2020, the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (Appellate Tribunal) has dismissed the appeal filed by Maruti Clean Coal and Power Limited (MCCPL), thereby upholding the Order dated 27.11.2019 passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Central Commission). The Appellate Tribunal has ruled in favour of the Rajasthan Discoms — Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited, Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited and Jodhpur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited and Rajasthan Urja Vikas Nigam Limited (RUVNL), rejecting MCCPL’s claim that the Scheduled Delivery Date (SDD) of 30.11.2016 fixed under the Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) stood revised to 01.04.2017, and that the first contract year for tariff purposes ought to be reckoned from the later date.

1. Delay of Two Years in seeking Long-Term Access cannot be termed as Force Majeure

MCCPL had attributed its inability to supply the full Aggregate Contracted Capacity of 250 MW by the SDD on the non-operationalization of Long-Term Access (LTA)/Medium-Term Open Access (MTOA), and sought to characterise this as a Force Majeure event under the PPA. The Appellate Tribunal rejected this contention. It noted that after submitting a LTA revision request, MCCPL “just adopted a wait and watch approach” and neither sent any reminder to PGCIL/CTU nor made any other effort to ensure that LTA for the full 250 MW was granted expeditiously, following up only on 13.08.2015, after its plant had already achieved Commercial Operation Date. The fresh LTA application, mandated because the change in target region exceeded 100 MW under the Connectivity Regulations, 2009, was filed over two years after the PPA was signed.

The Appellate Tribunal found no merit in MCCPL’s plea that this delay was attributable to “legal uncertainty and procedural ambiguity” on account of the methodology for calculating relinquishement charges pending before the Central Commission. It held that the fifth proviso to Regulation 12(1) of the Connectivity Regulations, 2009 “clearly provided that a fresh LTA application would be required” for a change exceeding 100 MW or a change of region, and the order on relinquishement charges passed by the Central Commission “only elaborates and explains” what the proviso already provided, without effecting any change in the regulatory position. Since Force Majeure grants relief only where the triggering event “could not have been avoided if the affected party had taken reasonable care or complied with prudent utility practices,” the Appellate Tribunal held that MCCPL “neither took reasonable care nor acted prudently” in pursuing its LTA request.

2. Commencement of supply “Upto” Aggregate Contracted Capacity does not require the entire quantum of electricity flowing

MCCPL’s case was that the SDD stood fulfilled only when the entire 250 MW commenced flowing, and that part supply of 45 MW alone on 30.11.2016 could not amount to commencement of supply under the PPA. The Appellate Tribunal disagreed, construing Article 4.1.1 and Article 4.2.1(b) together. It held that the expression “upto the Aggregated Contracted Capacity” indicates that “the seller may commence supply of power of any quantum, the maximum limit being the aggregated contracted capacity,” and that it was “not mandatory for the power generator i.e. the seller to supply the entire aggregated contracted capacity of power by the Scheduled Delivery Date i.e. 30.11.2016 in order to constitute commencement of supply of power.”

The Apellate Tribunal noted that MCCPL had itself served the advance preliminary notice (26.09.2016) and final written notice (27.10.2016) under Article 4.1.2 for commencement of supply “w.e.f 30.11.2016 i.e scheduled delivery date,” raised monthly invoices at the tariff payable for the first contract year, which were duly paid, and never conveyed to the Discoms that the SDD should be treated as suspended, split into phases, or held in abeyance pending availability of transmission capacity for the balance 205 MW. On this basis, the AppellateTribunal held that the supply of 45 MW from 30.11.2016 itself constituted “commencement of supply” under Article 4.1.1, and that the first Contract Year commenced from that date.

3. No Force Majeure event affected CTU, LTA was, in Fact, Operationalized ahead of Schedule

The Appellate Tribunal also rejected MCCPL’s reliance on Article 9.2.2, which deems a Force Majeure event affecting CTU/STU to be a Force Majeure event affecting the Seller. It observed that the 23rd Meeting of WR Constituents had recorded that the Champa-Kurukshetra HVDC Phase-I and Phase-II lines, and the Jabalpur-Orai line, were expected to be commissioned only in November 2016/March 2018 and April 2018 respectively, yet MCCPL’s LTA was in fact operationalized on 31.03.2017, “almost one year earlier” than the timeline earlier communicated by PGCIL. In these circumstances, the Appellate Tribunal held, “it cannot be said that there was any force majeure event affecting the PGCIL/CTU for providing transmission access to the appellant.”

4. Deliberate delay in Furnishing the Letter of Credit

The Appellate Tribunal found that even after the Champa-Kurukshetra line achieved Commercial Operation on 24.03.2017 and PGCIL/CTU called upon MCCPL on the same date to furnish a Letter of Credit (LC), MCCPL offered “no justification” for the delay in submitting the LC until 31.03.2017, resulting in commencement of the balance 205 MW supply only from 01.04.2017. The Appellate Tribunal held that this appeared to be a deliberate delay with an “ulterior motive,” observing that had supply commenced on any date between 24.03.2017 and 01.04.2017, the first contract year “would have been merely of a few days,” which MCCPL avoided so as to secure the higher first-contract-year tariff of Rs.1.633/kWh (as against Rs.1.558/kWh for the second Contract Year) for a full twelve-month period. The Appellate Tribunal termed such conduct “not acceptable.”

Conclusion

Holding that neither the delay in operationalization of LTA nor the timing of supply of the balance 205 MW was covered by Force Majeure under the PPA, and that commencement of supply of 45 MW on 30.11.2016 itself marked the beginning of the first contract year, the Appellate Tribunal answered both issues framed for its consideration against MCCPL. Finding no error or infirmity in the Impugned Order, the Appellate Tribunal dismissed Appeal No.183 of 2020, reaffirming that Scheduled Delivery Dates fixed under a PPA cannot be unilaterally shifted by a generator based on its own commercial convenience, and that claims of Force Majeure must be tested strictly against the diligence or lack thereof shown by the party invoking it.

Judgment Link

Read More
Share

About Us

Serving clients with unwavering dedication and ethical principles for more than a decade. Step in confidently knowing that you are in capable hands.

Service Offerings

  • Company Registration in India
  • Business Setup in India
  • Startup Lawyers in India
  • Media and Entertainment Legal Services
  • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
  • Gaming & Sports Law Services
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Infrastructure and Energy Law Firm in Delhi
    • Captive Power Lawyers in India

Other Services

  • Labour and Employment Law Services
  • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
  • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Lawyers
  • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
  • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
  • UK | R Associates
  • US | R Associates

Stay Connected

O-24/A, Jangpura Extension, New Delhi -110014
Get Directions

C-9, Plot No. 213, First Floor, Industrial Area, Phase-I, Chandigarh
Get Directions

Email: [email protected]

Phone: 011-36865659

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 R Associates. All Rights Reserved.

As per the rules of the Bar Council of India, we are not permitted to solicit work and advertise. The user acknowledges that there has been no advertisement and personal communication from R Associates, any information obtained or material downloaded from this website is completely of the user’s volition and any transmission, receipt, or use of this site would not create any lawyer-client relationship. In cases where the user has any legal issues, he/she in all cases must seek independent legal advice.

  • ↓
  • Reach Out To Us