
APTEL Restores the ROE from 11% to 13% ROE for Extended PPA Period by Holding That GERC Is Bound by Its Own Tariff Regulations and Tariff Order
Gujarat State Electricity Corporation Limited v. Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission & Anr., Appeal Nos. 301 of 2026 and 317 of 2026, decided on 23 October 2026
The Dispute
The appeals arose from orders of Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission (‘GERC’)approving the Supplementary Power Purchase Agreements (‘SPPAs’) extending the procurement of power from GSECL’s transferred generating stations and Wanakbori Thermal Power Station, Unit-7 (‘WTPS-7’). The dispute concerned the applicable Return on Equity (‘RoE’) during the extended PPA period.
GSECL had entered into an SPPA dated 18.02.2025 with GUVNL for the transferred generating stations, covering an aggregate capacity of 2912 MW, while the SPPA for WTPS-7 was executed on 13.11.2024 for its 210 MW capacity. The extensions were contemplated up to 01.04.2030 or the useful life of the respective stations, whichever was earlier.
Under the GERC MYT Regulations, 2024, Regulation 35.2 prescribes a base RoE of 13%. GERC had also, in its tariff order dated 31.03.2025, determined tariff for FY 2025-26 to FY 2029-30 and applied the 13% base RoE to the concerned generating stations.
However, while approving the SPPAs, GERC passed orders dated 26.05.2026 and 17.06.2026, restricting RoE during the extended PPA period to 11% and directing GSECL to furnish an unconditional undertaking permanently foregoing the differential 2% RoE.
The Issue Before APTEL
The principal question before the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (‘APTEL’) was whether GERC could, while approving the extended PPAs, reduce the normative RoE from 13% to 11% in circumstances where the applicable Regulations prescribed 13% and GSECL had not voluntarily claimed a lower RoE.
GSECL contended that the first proviso to Regulation 35.2 permits a lower RoE only where the generating company itself makes an unconditional claim for such lower RoE. It was therefore submitted that the provision did not confer an independent power upon GERC to suo motu impose a lower RoE.
APTEL’s Findings
APTEL held that 13% is the prescribed normative base RoE under Regulation 35.2, and that the mechanism for a lower RoE under the first proviso operates only upon a voluntary claim by the concerned regulated entity.
APTEL further noted that GERC MYT Regulations, 2024 contain no provision authorising GERC to prescribe a lower RoE merely because a generating station has completed its useful life.
APTEL relied on PTC India Ltd. v. CERC, (2010) 4 SCC 603 to hold that regulations framed under the Electricity Act have binding force and that state commission regulatory orders cannot override or effectively amend those regulations. Any departure from the prescribed regulatory framework would amount to impermissible legislation through an order.
APTEL also considered that GERC had itself approved 13% RoE for the same generating stations in its tariff order dated 31.03.2025, which had not been challenged and had therefore attained finality. Further, substantial capital expenditure had been approved for these stationsRs. 3,584 crore for the transferred generating stations and Rs. 214.86 crore for WTPS-7—supporting the application of the regulatory framework governing return on approved investment.
Regulatory Significance
The judgment reinforces an important regulatory principle that the State Commission cannot use a tariff or approval order to create a tariff treatment that is not contemplated by its governing Regulations.
The judgment also draws a clear distinction between regulatory discretion within the framework of existing Regulations and an attempt to alter that framework through an individual tariff order.
Read More