logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-36865659
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-36865659
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
      • Captive Power
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory & Compliance
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
      • Civil Litigation
      • Commercial Litigation
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution
    • Gaming & Sports
    • Real Estate
    • Private Client Practice
      • Estate & Succession Planning
      • Family Settlements, HUF & Partition
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
by R AssociatesNovember 6, 2026 Recent News0 comments

The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal Upholds Admissibility of Price and Quantity Variations in Transmission Capital Cost: Feasibility Report Estimates Are Indicative, Not Sacrosanct

The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (“Appellate Tribunal”), by its judgment dated 9 September 2026 in TANGEDCO v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors., Appeal No. 230 of 2016, has upheld the capital cost approved for the Vallur Thermal Power Station (“TPS”)–Melakottaiyur 400 kV Double Circuit (“D/C”) transmission line, forming part of the supplementary transmission system associated with Vallur TPS in the Southern Region. The judgment affirms the position consistently advanced by Power Grid Corporation of India Limited (“POWERGRID”) that the estimates contained in a Feasibility Report (“FR”) are indicative in nature and that variations in quantities and prices arising during execution are admissible in the capital cost, subject to a prudence check of the actual expenditure incurred.

The appeal arose from the order dated 27 November 2015 passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (“CERC”) in Petition No. 48/TT/2013, determining the tariff for the transmission line from its commercial operation date (“COD”) until 31 March 2014 under the CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009. TANGEDCO challenged the approved completion cost of Rs.58.71 crore against the FR estimate of Rs.46.38 crore, representing an increase of approximately 26.58%. It also questioned the admissibility of Incidental Expenditure During Construction (“IEDC”) and contended that CERC had failed to provide adequate reasons for allowing the increase in capital cost.

POWERGRID’s Submissions Before Appellate Tribunal

1. Quantity Variations are an Inherent Feature of Transmission Projects

POWERGRID submitted that the quantities specified in the Feasibility Report (“FR”) are based on preliminary surveys and are indicative of the estimated project cost, with actual requirements ascertainable only after detailed surveys, route profiling and soil investigations. It further contended that Right of Way (“RoW”) constraints, particularly the approximately 46-metre RoW requirement for a 400 kV D/C transmission line under the CBIP Manual, may necessitate changes in alignment and additional towers, foundations, tower steel and insulators. Accordingly, the increase in quantities arising from actual site conditions could not be disallowed merely because it exceeded the preliminary estimates in the FR.

2. Price Variation Is Governed by Contractual Mechanisms and Actual Market Conditions

POWERGRID submitted that the increase in capital cost was attributable to fluctuations in the prices of key inputs, including steel, cement and aluminium, and was calculated in accordance with the price variation clauses incorporated in its supply contracts, using predetermined formulae and applicable indices, including those published by the Indian Electrical and Electronics Manufacturers’ Association (“IEEMA”). It placed the supporting indices and computation methodology before CERC through an affidavit dated 24.09.2015 and relied on Manchukonda Agrotech Pvt. Ltd. v. KERC, Appeal No. 259 of 2018, to support its contention that actual cost data, rather than preliminary estimates alone, must be considered while determining admissible expenditure.

3. Actual Capital Cost Is Admissible Subject to Prudence Check

POWERGRID submitted that Regulations 7 and 9 of the CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009, require capital cost to be determined on the basis of actual expenditure, subject to prudence check, and that the increase over the FR estimate could not, by itself, justify disallowance of expenditure incurred for executing the project. It further contended that Incidental Expenditure During Construction (“IEDC”) is a recognised component of capital cost and is admissible in accordance with the applicable Tariff Regulations, the expenditure being duly supported by Auditor’s Certificates.

The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal’s Findings and Observations

The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal upheld the capital cost approved for the transmission asset and rejected TANGEDCO’s challenge, making the following key findings:

  1. The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal held that the quantities indicated in a Detailed Project Report (“DPR”) or preliminary estimate cannot be treated as an absolute ceiling on capital cost under Section 62 of the Electricity Act, 2003. Any increase in quantities must be assessed on the basis of actual project requirements and is admissible subject to prudence check under the applicable Tariff Regulations.
  2. The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal recognised the enforceability of contractually agreed price variation mechanisms. In the present case, POWERGRID relied on the Supply Contract Agreement dated 24.03.2011, which provided for price adjustment. After considering the applicable indices and calculations placed before CERC, the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal rejected TANGEDCO’s objection to the application of price variation for the period from the first quarter of 2010 to October 2012.
  3. The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal upheld the determination of capital cost on the basis of actual expenditure, subject to regulatory scrutiny. It noted that CERC had considered TANGEDCO’s objections and POWERGRID’s explanations before accepting that the increase in cost arose from actual execution requirements and prevailing market conditions. However, the expenditure must be adequately substantiated and satisfy the prescribed prudence check.
  4. The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal held that the Comptroller and Auditor General’s Performance Audit Report No. 18 of 2014 could not, by itself, constitute sufficient grounds for disallowing an otherwise admissible increase in capital cost. The expenditure must instead be examined on the basis of project-specific circumstances, supporting evidence, contractual provisions and the applicable regulatory framework.
  5. The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal upheld the treatment of IEDC, which CERC had provisionally allowed at Rs. 464.55 lakh, within the stipulated limit of 5% of the hard cost, subject to furnishing year-wise actual expenditure at the time of true-up. The admissibility of IEDC remains subject to compliance with the applicable Tariff Regulations and verification of actual expenditure.
  6. While upholding the capital cost, the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal observed that CERC should have provided more detailed reasons, particularly while dealing with substantial cost overruns. However, noting that tariff determination is a continuing process and that the asset had subsequently undergone tariff determination and true-up for later periods, the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal exercised its appellate jurisdiction under Section 111 of the Electricity Act, 2003, to decide the dispute on merits rather than remand the matter for reconsideration.

The judgment affirms POWERGRID’s position that preliminary estimates in a Feasibility Report or Detailed Project Report cannot be treated as an inflexible ceiling on the capital cost of a transmission project. Variations in quantities arising from route realignment, Right of Way constraints, soil conditions and other site-specific requirements, as well as price variations permitted under contractual mechanisms, may legitimately contribute to an increase in the final project cost. However, such increases are not automatically admissible and must be supported by adequate evidence, comply with the contractual provisions and satisfy the prudence check prescribed under the applicable Tariff Regulations, thereby balancing the recovery of justified expenditure against the need to protect beneficiaries from imprudent or inadequately substantiated costs.

Further, by adjudicating the dispute on merits rather than remanding the tariff order dating back to 2015, the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal has brought finality to the proceedings, notwithstanding the subsequent tariff determination and true-up of the asset. The judgment reinforces regulatory certainty for transmission licensees by recognising the practical realities of executing transmission projects while clarifying that the admissibility of capital cost must be determined on the basis of actual expenditure, its justification and regulatory prudence, rather than merely its deviation from preliminary estimates. It is, therefore, relevant to future tariff proceedings involving cost overruns attributable to genuine execution requirements and contractually permissible price variations.

Judgment Link

Read More
Share
by R AssociatesOctober 26, 2026 Recent News0 comments

APTEL Verdict: Under-utilisation of Transmission Assets No Bar to Commercial Operation or Recovery of Charges through the PoC Mechanism

The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal for Electricity has upheld POWERGRID’s contention that a transmission asset placed in regular service achieves commercial operation irrespective of the extent of its utilisation, and upon commercial operation, its charges are recoverable through the Point of Connection (‘PoC’) mechanism. The Tribunal thereby rejected the challenge of Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd. (‘TANGEDCO’) to the commercial operation and PoC recovery of the Tuticorin–Salem transmission corridor planned for the generation projects of Coastal Energen Private Limited (Coastal Energen) and Ind-Barath Power (Madras) Limited (Ind-Barath).

The Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, in its judgment dated 13 October 2026 in Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. (Appeal Nos. 56 and 329 of 2018), has delivered a significant ruling upholding the position consistently taken by Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. (POWERGRID) before the Central Commission and the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal.

TANGEDCO had challenged the Central Commission’s orders dated 19.09.2017 in Petition No. 235/TT/2016 and 21.11.2017 in Petition No. 71/TT/2017, which approved the date of commercial operation (COD) of the assets as 13.11.2016 and 23.10.2016 respectively and directed recovery of their charges through the PoC mechanism. TANGEDCO contended that the system was planned for 2,000 MW of Long-Term Access (LTA), of which only 558 MW was tied up through its Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) with Coastal Energen. It argued that the assets were therefore never put to “beneficial use”, and that charges for the unutilised 1,442 MW ought to be borne by the generators rather than the Designated Inter-State Transmission System Customers (DICs).

POWERGRID’s Contentions Before the Tribunal

Throughout the proceedings, POWERGRID consistently advanced the following positions:

1. The Assets Achieved COD upon being placed in Regular Service

  • POWERGRID argued that the assets were completed in accordance with the CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014. TANGEDCO’s own admitted drawal of 558 MW from Coastal Energen through the system established actual use from commissioning.
  • It was submitted that the Regional Load Despatch Centre (RLDC) charging certificate and Central Electricity Authority (CEA) clearance merely corroborated regular service. The non-commissioning of Ind-Barath and right-of-way delays fell within proviso (ii) to Regulation 4(3), being reasons not attributable to the transmission licensee.

2. The Scheme was Implemented under a Final Regulatory Approval

  • POWERGRID highlighted that the corridor was implemented under the Central Commission’s regulatory approval dated 31.05.2010 in Petition No. 233 of 2009, as permitted by Clause 22.7(iv) of the Detailed Procedure, 2009.
  • TANGEDCO participated in those proceedings and never challenged that order. Its challenge to the necessity of the corridor was therefore an impermissible and belated collateral attack.
  • Both generators had executed Bulk Power Transmission Agreements and furnished bank guarantees. Ind-Barath first disclosed abandonment only at the 15th Joint Coordination Committee (JCC) meeting on 10.06.2016, when the assets were already at an advanced stage.
  • The 765 kV corridor, initially charged at 400 kV, was planned for about 6,500 MW of concentrated coastal generation in the Tuticorin area, so as to conserve right of way.

3. The Assets form part of the Meshed Inter-State Transmission Network and are Recoverable through PoC

  • POWERGRID submitted that the assets form part of a common meshed network serving multiple users, not a system dedicated to the two generators.
  • PoC recovery was therefore consistent with Regulation 43 of the 2014 Tariff Regulations read with the CERC (Sharing of Inter-State Transmission Charges and Losses) Regulations, 2010.
  • The liability of Generator for relinquished LTA is addressed through relinquishment charges determined in Petition No. 92/MP/2015. Having implemented the assets after regulatory approval and incurred substantial expenditure and debt, POWERGRID could not be denied its legitimate transmission charges.

Hon’ble Tribunal’s Findings

The Hon’ble Tribunal upheld POWERGRID’s contentions and the Central Commission’s orders, holding that:

i) Regulation 4(3) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations requires the asset to be in regular service. “Regular use” must be distinguished from the “full use” on which TANGEDCO insisted.

ii) Transmission lines are lumpy assets planned over a long horizon and cannot be augmented in small increments. The N-1 reliability criterion itself requires lines to operate below their thermal capacity.

iii) Once an asset is completed, commissioned and capable of performing its intended function, the absence of full utilisation cannot postpone its COD. PSPCL v. PGCIL (Appeal No. 123 of 2011) was held inapplicable.

iv) The regulatory remedy for stranded capacity is relinquishment compensation under Regulation 18 of the 2009 Connectivity Regulations. Under Regulation 18(3), that compensation reduces the charges payable by other long-term and medium-term customers.

v) Clause 22.7(iv) of the Detailed Procedure permitted the scheme with the Central Commission’s approval, granted on 31.05.2010. By the time Ind-Barath disclosed abandonment, execution had progressed too far to be altered.

vi) The entire 2 x 660 MW of Coastal Energen, Kudankulam Nuclear Power Project (2 x 1,000 MW) and Tuticorin JV (2 x 500 MW) are pooled at Tuticorin Pooling Station.

vii) Likening planning agencies to an architect and the transmission licensee to a contractor, the Tribunal held that fixed-cost recovery turns on whether capacity is created, commissioned, maintained and kept available, not on power flow at a given time.

viii) The non-materialisation of planning assumptions was not attributable to POWERGRID, which implemented the approved scheme. Charges are recoverable under the 2010 Sharing Regulations, subject to prudence check of capital cost.

ix) Brevity of reasoning was no ground to set them aside, as the Tribunal decided the substantive challenge on merits. Both appeals were dismissed.

This judgment marks a significant affirmation of POWERGRID’s consistent stand before the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission and the Hon’ble Appellate Tribunal.

The ruling provides regulatory certainty to transmission licensees. Once a scheme approved by the competent authorities is implemented, commissioned and kept available, recovery of admissible tariff cannot be made hostage to the fortunes of the generators for whom it was planned.

It recognises the anticipatory and lumpy nature of transmission planning, while the relinquishment mechanism under the Connectivity Regulations shields other DICs from the cost of stranded capacity. This decision is a significant victory for POWERGRID and reinforces the stability of the PoC framework on which inter-State transmission investment depends.

Read More
Share

About Us

Serving clients with unwavering dedication and ethical principles for more than a decade. Step in confidently knowing that you are in capable hands.

Service Offerings

  • Company Registration in India
  • Business Setup in India
  • Startup Lawyers in India
  • Media and Entertainment Legal Services
  • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
  • Gaming & Sports Law Services
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Infrastructure and Energy Law Firm in Delhi
    • Captive Power Lawyers in India

Other Services

  • Labour and Employment Law Services
  • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
  • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Lawyers
  • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
  • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
  • UK | R Associates
  • US | R Associates

Stay Connected

O-24/A, Jangpura Extension, New Delhi -110014
Get Directions

C-9, Plot No. 213, First Floor, Industrial Area, Phase-I, Chandigarh
Get Directions

Email: [email protected]

Phone: 011-36865659

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 R Associates. All Rights Reserved.

As per the rules of the Bar Council of India, we are not permitted to solicit work and advertise. The user acknowledges that there has been no advertisement and personal communication from R Associates, any information obtained or material downloaded from this website is completely of the user’s volition and any transmission, receipt, or use of this site would not create any lawyer-client relationship. In cases where the user has any legal issues, he/she in all cases must seek independent legal advice.

  • ↓
  • Reach Out To Us