logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-40743543
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-40743543
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
June 19, 2023 by Anumeha Smiti Articles 0 comments

E-Sports and Specialised Arbitration Mechanism

Traditionally, the utility of sports was limited to personal entertainment. Steadily, the scope of sports was widened to include broadcasting, endorsements, franchisees, etc, thereby making it a commercially profitable venture. By the late 1990s, another unique integration of online gaming experience – electronic sports or e-Sports began to take shape as high revenue generating competitive sports; and with the advent of the new millennium, e-Sports started attracting significant sponsorship and investment. 

Electronic sports or e-Sports are a form of sports that involve electronic systems as the primary facilitators of the sport with human-computer interfaces mediating the input and output of players and teams. Its distinguishing features include flexibility of location, a vast prize pool and the need for updating the format of the game at quick intervals. With the increasing competitiveness, vast prize pools, and a formalisation of the online gaming industry, e-Sports – Premier leagues and championships, now generate huge revenue and account for about 3% of World trade. 

While the domain of traditional sports has aged well with a definite regulatory framework, the e-Sports industry, being in its nascent stages, is still dependent on contracts. Such contractual relations among the stakeholders and a huge revenue generation attributable to sponsorship and advertisements make the e-Sports industry vulnerable to exploitation and corruption. In the era of continuous growth, a regulatory regime for e-Sports is the need of the hour. 

Resolution of e-Sports disputes

The resolution of e-Sports disputes is similar to any other commercial and employment disputes. However, owing to the nature of such disputes, they are time-sensitive. The e-Sports industry is fast-paced and a long-drawn lawsuit takes a heavy toll on the career of the players and on the overall revenue generation of the industry. Even in a seemingly trivial contract dispute that is under adjudication, the player is barred from participating in e-Sports events during the pendency of such adjudication. This results in an unfair and disproportionate punishment on the player even if, the result of the adjudication comes in his favour. Moreover, attributable to the locational flexibility, delineation of jurisdiction for the resolution of e-Sports disputes through litigation is not a feasible option. 

In this context, Arbitration provides a quicker, confidential and cost-effective resolution of e-Sports disputes by industry experts/content area specialists acting as Arbitrators.  

Specialised Arbitration mechanism for e-Sports

The Court of Arbitration for Sports (‘CAS’) has proved to be a specialised arbitration platform for various sports disputes. It has about 300 arbitrators from 87 countries, with specialised knowledge of Arbitration and sports law. Considering the similarity between traditional sports and e-Sports, CAS is often treated as an obvious platform for e-Sports disputes. However, the lack of domain-specific knowledge of e-Sports eliminates CAS as a potential mechanism for the resolution of e-Sports disputes. 

The e-Sports Integrity Coalition (‘ESIC’) was introduced as a suitable platform for specialised dispute resolution, but its subject matter jurisdiction was restricted to disciplinary matters. To cater to the growing need for a specialised Arbitration mechanism in e-Sports, the World e-Sports Association (‘WESA’) launched the Arbitration Court for e-Sports (‘ACES’) with an objective to provide a mechanism similar to CAS but dedicated exclusively to e-Sports. The ACES was also an improvement over ESIC as it provided for the resolution of disciplinary as well as commercial disputes.

Challenges Faced in Specialised Arbitration

The efficiency of an Arbitration institution depends on the proportion of parties in the industry subscribing to the rules of the institution. However, till date, there is no model Arbitration forum for e-Sports. 

Since the process of arbitration by the ACES is regulated by WESA, any affiliation of the WESA with a strong market player is detrimental to the independent image of the Arbitration proceedings and the impartiality of the arbitrators is always at risk. 

Freedom of contract is quintessential to arbitration. However, given the lopsided distribution of resources in the e-Sports industry where the players are mostly young and unaware of their rights and obligations, too much freedom acts to the disadvantage of the parties. 

Conclusion

Being in its formative stages, ACES can draw from other Arbitration platforms and provide such mechanisms, such as the International Chamber of Commerce (‘ICC’). For instance, the ACES’s rules state that an award is final and binding but the rules nowhere mention the steps to pursue an enforcement. In this case, the ACES can adhere to the rules of the ICC with respect to the enforcement of an award. 

Further, the impartiality provisions in the ACES rules are similar to its sports counterpart, CAS. Of late, the credibility of CAS has suffered because the arbitrators could not enforce the principles of impartiality and maintain independence. Drawing from the experience of CAS, the Arbitration Court for e-Sports should develop better provisions to ensure impartiality and independence.

Therefore, the e-Sports tournament organizers must endeavour to create a stakeholder-friendly adjudication mechanism, and in general, the e-Sports industry, as a whole, should ensure that a fair and expedient dispute resolution mechanism is in place.  

Court of Arbitration for e-Sports (ACES) dispute resolution e-Sports e-Sports industry online gaming online gaming disputes specialised arbitration
Share

Related Posts

Retroactive operation of laws and statutes
by Shikha SoodJune 8, 20231 comment

What Makes the Operation of a Law/Statute Retrospective?

Read More
Online Rummy
by R AssociatesSeptember 7, 20230 comments

The Legality of Online Rummy in India: A Comprehensive Insight

Read More
Foreign Investment Rules Applicable to Domestic Investments in Hydrocarbons
by R AssociatesOctober 3, 20240 comments

Foreign Investment Rules Applicable to Domestic Investments in Hydrocarbons

Read More
Complexities of Workplace Harassment in India A Call for Justice and Reform
by R AssociatesOctober 14, 20240 comments

Complexities of Workplace Harassment in India: A Call for Justice and Reform

Read More

Leave a Comment! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Exploring the Strategic Advantages of doing business in IndiaPrevious Post
Delhi High Court holds that an Arbitration clause does not survive on Novation of the ContractNext Post

About Us

Serving clients with unwavering dedication and ethical principles for more than a decade. Step in confidently knowing that you are in capable hands.

Service Offerings

  • Company Registration in India
  • Business Setup in India
  • Startup Lawyers in India
  • Media and Entertainment Legal Services
  • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
  • Gaming & Sports Law Services
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Infrastructure and Energy Law Firm in Delhi

Other Services

  • Labour and Employment Law Services
  • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
  • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
  • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
  • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
  • UK | R Associates
  • US | R Associates

Stay Connected

O-24/A, Jangpura Extension, New Delhi -110014

Email: [email protected]

Phone: 011-40743543
Get Directions

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 R Associates. All Rights Reserved.

As per the rules of the Bar Council of India, we are not permitted to solicit work and advertise. The user acknowledges that there has been no advertisement and personal communication from R Associates, any information obtained or material downloaded from this website is completely of the user’s volition and any transmission, receipt, or use of this site would not create any lawyer-client relationship. In cases where the user has any legal issues, he/she in all cases must seek independent legal advice.

  • ↓
  • Reach Out To Us