logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-40743543
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
logologo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
011-40743543
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Team
  • Expertise
    • Energy and Infrastructure
    • Property Law
    • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
    • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
    • Gaming & Sports Law Services
    • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
    • Labour & Employment
    • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Legal Alerts
    • Articles
    • Recent News
  • Contact Us
May 8, 2023 by R Associates Recent News 0 comments

Tribunal Lacks authority to negotiate or establish New Agreements on behalf of Parties

Supreme Court Overrules APTEL Judgment, Asserts Regulatory Commissions Cannot Overstep Express Contractual Provisions

The Honorable Supreme Court, constituted by the bench of Justices K. M. Joseph and B.V. Nagarthna, recently overturned a judgment issued by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL). The Supreme Court addressed the question of whether the Tribunal has the authority to renegotiate the terms of an agreement on behalf of the parties. The Court examined if the Commission under Section 79 of the Electricity Act, 2003 has a plenary power that could be characterized as an all-encompassing authority, enabling the Tribunal to disregard the contract’s express language, uncover a new change in law unanticipated by the parties, or ultimately rewrite the contract and establish a new agreement.

In Paragraph 95, the Supreme Court concluded that when a matter is governed by the contract’s explicit terms, it may not be permissible for the Commission, even as a regulatory body, to overstep those terms.

In its interpretation of the case Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission and Others (2017) 14 SCC 80, the Supreme Court observed that when the Commission is asked to exercise power under Section 63, it is beholden to the guidelines as it cannot depart from the same,” and that “in an area where the guidelines do not occupy the field, undoubtedly, the Commission is clothed with power as a regulatory body.

The Supreme Court expressed strong disapproval at the Tribunal’s findings, which were made without any supporting evidence and carried significant consequences. The Court allowed the appeals, stating that “the Tribunal was wrong in brushing aside the specific and unambiguous disclaimers under which the procurers stood exonerated from liability,” and that there was no change in law according to the terms of the PPA.

It has also been held that to successfully invoke change in law by the Generating Company, it must demonstrate that there was an interpretation earlier to or as on the date of the cut off date which was advantageous to the Generator and there has been a change in the said interpretation after the cut off date.

This ruling has been made in the context of Civil Appeals filed by Haryana Discoms, Punjab Discoms, Rajasthan Discoms, MP Discoms, UP Discoms, and Tata Power Distribution, which challenged the claims awarded by the Tribunal in favor of Sasan Power concerning (a) increased costs due to changes in the water intake system, (b) custom duty paid on mining equipment, and (c) the formula provided in the Power Purchase Agreement (“PPA”) for calculating relief on account of changes in the law.

Judgement: JUDGMENT DTD 06.04.2023 IN CA NO 11826 OF 2018

The team at R Associates, led by Shubham Arya (Partner) and Poorva Saigal (Partner) and comprising team members involving Pallavi Saigal (Senior Associate), Ravi Nair (Associate) Shikha Sood (Associate), Reeha Singh (Associate) and Anumeha Smiti (Associate) represented Haryana and Rajasthan Distribution Licensees before the Supreme Court. 

Share

Related Posts

APTEL Stays Order
by Ravi NairMay 31, 20230 comments

APTEL Stays The Order of Central Commission Allowing The Claim for Deemed Fixed Charges From Distribution Licensees Not Procuring Any Power As Claimed Under the Section 11 Directions Issued By The Ministry of Power

Read More
Unstamped Arbitration Agreements
by Pallavi SaigalMay 30, 20230 comments

Decoding the Supreme Court’s Stance on Unstamped Arbitration Agreements: A Legal Perspective

Read More
Unauthorized Power Injection
by Reeha SinghAugust 7, 20230 comments

Punjab State Commission Dismisses Unauthorized Power Injection Claim

Read More
by R AssociatesMarch 12, 20240 comments

The Himachal Pradesh High Court declared the water cess imposed on Hydropower Generation as unconstitutional, providing relief to power companies.

Read More

Leave a Comment! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Navigating India's Renewable Energy Policies: A Comprehensive Guide for Foreign InvestorsPrevious Post
Navigating the Virtual Playground: Online Gaming in IndiaNext Post

About Us

Serving clients with unwavering dedication and ethical principles for more than a decade. Step in confidently knowing that you are in capable hands.

Service Offerings

  • Company Registration in India
  • Business Setup in India
  • Startup Lawyers in India
  • Media and Entertainment Legal Services
  • Real Estate Lawyers in Delhi
  • Gaming & Sports Law Services
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Legal Services
  • Infrastructure and Energy Law Firm in Delhi

Other Services

  • Labour and Employment Law Services
  • Regulatory Compliance Law Services
  • Litigation & Dispute Resolution Legal Services
  • Corporate & Commercial Law Services
  • Alternate Dispute Resolution Legal Services
  • UK | R Associates
  • US | R Associates

Stay Connected

O-24/A, Jangpura Extension, New Delhi -110014

Email: [email protected]

Phone: 011-40743543
Get Directions

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2023 R Associates. All Rights Reserved.

As per the rules of the Bar Council of India, we are not permitted to solicit work and advertise. The user acknowledges that there has been no advertisement and personal communication from R Associates, any information obtained or material downloaded from this website is completely of the user’s volition and any transmission, receipt, or use of this site would not create any lawyer-client relationship. In cases where the user has any legal issues, he/she in all cases must seek independent legal advice.

  • ↓
  • Reach Out To Us